This is a follow up to the Media Frenzy post (here), which is about the tabloids making a lot of noise about Jimmy’s response to a crowd work question on Russell Brand (here) allegedly being used to sell tickets.
As mentioned in Media Frenzy – I’m not trying to get a point across about either the Brand or Walliams stories. I’m just really uncomfortable with the awful reporting that is using half-truths and innuendo as clickbait. That and the usual AI rubbish.
If you’re not familiar with this blog – there are a ton of posts on here that try to show how really poor reporting is now, especially with AI generated social accounts, blogs and websites.
See under:
These fact checking posts are because it concerns me how sloppy everything is getting. Because I am searching for citation links to things that I already know most of the facts about, they really stand out.
Forums like Reddit have all kinds of nonsensical / nasty posts (especially in the subs around comedy) that feed into the LLMs and are then regurgitated as factual. Add into that the clickbait tabloid pieces and we can see the reason why most people in the entertainment industry say, when asked, that they don’t Google themselves or read social media. Once you have any level of fame the online world is a toxic soup.
Examples below are mostly just about the comedy industry in general, but really, they apply to anyone in the limelight. And I should perhaps mention that, where I use a link from a single MSM site, I’ve picked an example that worked for the point being made. Once published though, that text is then replicated by the Yahoo’s of this world, local papers, foreign blogs and websites. And then the chain of “cut and paste” reporting (better described as AI scraping now) mean that we sometimes end up with an even more watered-down version of the facts.
FYI – I’m not IN the industry – I just adore comedy and have spent years watching it (live and on a screen), reading websites and forums most days and have heaps of books. Books about the history of comedy (both sides of the pond) and biographies (and Jimmy’s 3 books) and so on. Slightly obsessive.
I started this blog 2 years ago because (full disclosure) I’ve long been an admirer of Jimmy as both a comedian and TV host and thought his career deserved better than the treatment the Brit press hand out to him. This was my attempt to rebalance the Universe and turned into something bigger than I expected, TBH.
I’m probably not quite at the level of making comedy my specialist subject on Mastermind (although I might have a shot if JC were my chosen area of expertise) but I’ve collected enough knowledge to read stories and know when something is “off”.
Podcast Chums
This digital Salem is spraying effluent across all kinds of people and the final straw (that triggered this post) was this Daily Mail piece about David Walliams and his “podcast chums”. I’ve never much liked DW – this mini-rant is about a large media organisation writing about who appeared on a podcast and making a tenuous link to something unrelated.
In a nutshell, DW had a podcast with Matt Lucas and this article lists the people that appeared on it and states:
At time of publication, they still remained silent on the allegations.
This is the UK gutter press in action. Silence is violence etc.
WHY would someone be required to make a statement on something that is none of their business? And, if they do and they have a book or tour coming out, will they too be accused of shamelessly “cashing in” on the events surrounding these two men?
The tabloids / keyboard warriors keep demanding statements but then are not happy if they do happen to receive one. The recent furore over Ed Sheeran is an example of how saying ANYTHING just digs a deeper and deeper hole. Jonathan Ross made that mistake (here) and reactions include “he’s just trying to save his career”. Maybe, maybe not. I try to not call people that I don’t know liars when it’s also possible that they genuinely didn’t know anything (beyond roasting each other on comedy TV shows). I don’t know.
There are people that think “silence means you are complicit” but it’s often the best idea, because you are on a hiding to nothing if you go down the “explaining yourself” route.
Look at the Podcasts page (here) and see how many pods Jimmy does, when promoting a new tour.
People on the promo circuit go on pods and talk shows and are smiley and affable and may even hug each other – but it’s often 50-50 as to whether they’ve met each other before the handshake in the green room on the way in.
When agents book their “talent” on TV / pods they don’t exactly do CRB checks on the host or other guests…
Even if the guest / host says “we should meet up sometime” – that’s the same as business people shaking hands and saying “we should go for a beer”. They’re just pleasantries we all use, every day. The equivalent of “how are you?”.
And that follow-up “beer” rarely happens.
We see a similar thing when photos are dredged up from decades earlier as “evidence”. The bigger the name the more parties / events they are invited to and they will be asked (often by pro photographers at the event) to pose with lots and lots of other attendees. Doesn’t mean they know them. Doesn’t mean they know anything about what they get up to in their bedroom.
Unfortunately, what we have seen this week, is the tabloids / YouTubers are data-mining TV shows, podcasts, media interviews and so on. Looking for a stick to beat the next person with.
I don’t know about you – but I’m not happy about rumours for clickbait.
Female Comedians / WhatsApp Group
Over the last few years many references have been made to a WhatsApp group that female comedians have been using to warn each other about “predators”.
This Daily Mail piece has the Walliams name at the top and is referring to an interview with Kate Smurthwaite.
Although I know the name it’s likely that not all of you will heard of Kate as a comedian (and political activist) – and that is kind of pivotal to my point because she’s a circuit comedian. Nothing wrong with that (it’s how Jimmy started out) but I’m using that term to set the scene.
There are references to car sharing on the way to gigs and this is the first indicator that although “Ms Smurthwaite said Walliams ‘came up over and over’ again” I can’t see how any of the screenshots of the posts could possibly refer to DW.
There are 2 facts there that should be kept apart. Clearly, he was being talked about (1) – but the WhatsApp posts were about other men (2). The problem being, if you read the comments under the story, no one else grasps that.
Just to muddy the waters further one screenshot says “Hi has anyone gigged for xxxxxxxxxx or xxxxxxxxxx with any bad experience”. That can only be about a promoter because it says gigged FOR. More slightly shaky information.
Another screenshot refers to someone booking gigs under a different name and being on the same line-up in a gig (as whoever posted). Again, that wouldn’t be DW.
So, what we have here, is a story that LOOKS like it’s about one person – but uses “evidence” relating to several others. Anyone else uncomfortable with that level of fudging? Forget who the story is referencing…isn’t this shoddy journalism?
Friends, colleagues or acquaintances?
My other irritation, that is spread across every one of the myriad of MSM pieces (and all of the podcasts) is the blurring of the lines between being a real friend and laughing with work colleagues.
When I walk around where I live, I meet people that I have “known” for years. Some I know which house they live in, many more I know their dog’s name (dog person) – but I don’t have their contact details or know very much about their lives. I’m “friendly with” them but they are not quite “friends”. More like acquaintances.
Another kind of “categorisation”friend level” (which tends to apply to a lot of male “friendships”) would be “blokes I go to the footie with”. That’s a loose bond built on a shared passion – but blokes are not known for chatting about “personal” stuff at the best of times and so most of them wouldn’t know what their football mates get up to after hours.
Then again, when it comes to events like Wimbledon, for example, tickets are often given to famous fans and then you can end up with people that don’t know each other being sat together (the ones in the stands). Kind of like a celebrity enclosure, that the cameras can pan to. Once again – sitting NEAR someone doesn’t mean that you know them well enough to be told their darkest secrets.
Friends (real friends) are the people that you would ring at 3 in the morning to ask them to take you to hospital. The people that you phone up to sob down the phone to, when your dog dies.
Or, if you listen to what Jimmy says in this clip, the people that you, your other half and kids spend Christmas with. Spoiler alert – the initials are DM and his wife is V.
What we have with the tabloids (and the “burn the witch” type of keyboard warrior) is an assumption that any 2 people that have been in a TV studio together MUST be best mates. That they go on the BFQ and sit chatting about who they assaulted the night before.
That fuzzy definition of friendship is being used (especially this week) to imply that people “knew something” and to demand “why didn’t they speak up”.
The amount of “guilt by association” aspersions being made is just depressing.
Would the people, venting in comments, like it if their career was on the line because of rumours, assumptions and/or lies about them, because of something someone at their workplace did?
Another part of the problem here is that “the internet never forgets”. Back in 2006, when The Naked Jape was published (here) Jimmy described his co-author (Lucy Greeves) as his “best friend at Uni”. I would imagine that they are still in each other’s contact lists and may even describe each other as still being friends – but it’s probable that they are not still in each other’s day-to-day lives.
Much like all the names swimming around in my phone contacts. You leave them there “just in case” but have no idea where that person is, what they are doing, who they are with etc. If someone in my contacts list committed murder, would I be asked why I didn’t suspect them and make a public statement?
Am I labouring my point here? (wish this platform had an emoji feature).
Can we please go back to due process and the judicial system and lose the kangaroo courts?
AI having its say
Just to twist the truth a leeeettttle more – we have AI chipping in. And it rarely has anything sensible to say…
I was actually looking for some links/dates for a forthcoming Ed Byrne story when these Question links caught my eye.
I’m not sure either of the statements below are entirely accurate from the perspective that I’ve never seen Jimmy socialise with either Jon or Sean.
I don’t doubt that they loved working together and had a comedic bond that built during the 100s of shows that they worked on. But, by the definitions above, are they “friends or, less likely, “best friends”?
AI doesn’t understand that level of nuance and so serves up Sean as the answer to “who is Jimmy’s best friend”.
Normally this wouldn’t matter but, after the events of this week, just being DESCRIBED as a friend could destroy a career.
As an aside, after Sean’s death I always thought Bill Bailey seemed slightly pushed aside (by the press) as he had described Sean as like his older brother, across their 30 year friendship, and talks in the Independent here about them going for long walks and having picnics. Now THAT sounds more like a best friend than work colleague.

I’ve bored on long enough.
If you got this far – well done. Now go and watch some comedy.
Leave a Reply